Having a
voice is what makes us human. The ability to speak our minds and express our
feelings through words is something that no other creature can. (Or at least as
far as we know.) With our voices we are able connect with people, change minds,
build bridges, and stand up for ourselves. Our voices also allow us to advocate
for ourselves. If we believe something is wrong or unjust we can speak up and
try to invoke change. However, the ability to decide what happens to us is a
privilege that many Americans take for granted. Nearly all humans can physically express their
opinions, but not all people possess the right to free speech. In countries
like Russia and Syria “freedom of speech” is not a natural born right. If
people say the wrong things they can be jailed or even killed. They don’t have
a say in a lot of things that happen to them, and can’t even complain about
their country’s wrongdoings.
Like most
people, when I think of oppression of speech I think of food. Specifically apples.
I love apples. I pretty much eat one every day. An apple doesn't have freedom
of speech. It has no say in where it grows up, when it leaves the tree, and
whether it gets a career in pie, applesauce, or simply stays in its original
state. An apple’s life is entirely determined by other things. It doesn't have
the privilege of being able to advocate for itself.
Everyone
remembers a time when they were afraid to do something. Maybe it was riding a
bike without training wheels, going on a roller coaster, or sleeping over at
someone else’s house. Regardless, we've all been afraid. However, we've been
able to say the words, “no, I’m not ready,” and then been allowed to try the
bike the next day or ride the roller coaster the following year. An apple can’t
do that. Maybe it’s not ready to leave the tree and all its friends, but can it
advocate for itself? No! If someone else wants to pick that apple, it is saying
goodbye to the tree right then and there. The apple is taken from its home
without warning and can’t prevent the situation from happening.
The
oppression of speech doesn't end there. The apple is also unable to decide what
it becomes. Its career goal might be to end up part of a piece of apple
strudel, but it’s unable to try and make that happen. It’s completely at the
mercy of its surroundings.
When
people’s voices are silenced it’s like they’re apples. Without voices they are
just flotsam in the sea. They're like chess pieces, their lives lie in the hands of others. They have no identity, no individuality, and no say in
what happens to them. People aren't apples, they’re people. They have feelings,
thoughts, and opinions, all of which should not be condemned.
I like the risk you're taking with the apple analogy, Trey. And I especially like that you just went for it. At the same time, it IS risky. The idea of an apple being oppressed through silence, an apple who doesn't get to choose if he's streudel or sauce is--well--a little bit funny, and you risk us losing the seriousness of your argument about voicelessness. But the writing is clear and articulate, and the thinking is worthwhile.
ReplyDelete